TV Commercial Production: AI vs Studio
TV commercial production with AI vs traditional crews: previs, post, broadcast and CTV specs, clearance, disclosure, and who makes the spot.
Published 2026-04-29 · Updated 2026-11-17 · AI Video Production · By Tommaso Maria Ricci, Founder of Neverframe
TV Commercial Production in 2026: AI, Traditional Studios, and the New Hybrid Playbook
In May 2025 Nielsen recorded a month in which Americans spent more TV time on streaming than on broadcast and cable put together. Two months later the IAB reported that most video ad buyers were already building creative with generative AI. Marketing departments are re-planning TV commercial production this year because viewers moved to a different screen while the tools for making a spot were changing.
A traditional shoot still gives you the most control over human performance and real product in real light, and it costs the most in days, people and money. An AI-produced spot removes the shoot, so it moves faster and is easier to turn into versions. Its quality depends on the director and on how carefully the film is finished. Most campaigns in 2026 mix the two. The rest of this guide covers where AI helps in previsualization and post, how AI creative performs against filmed work, what premium placements require, and who should produce the spot.
What TV Commercial Production Actually Includes
Start with the plain definition. Wikipedia describes the format this way:
"A television advertisement (also called a commercial, spot, break, advert, or ad) is a span of television programming produced and paid for by an organization."
A production has four parts, whether it is filmed or generated.
Creative development. Strategy, concept, script and storyboard. This is where the idea is decided, and it is the cheapest place to change your mind. A production-ready script follows a fixed layout, shown in these commercial script examples.
Pre-production. Casting, locations, wardrobe, design and scheduling on a filmed job. On an AI job the same phase covers look development, character and product references, and a shot plan.
Production. The shoot days on a set, or the generation phase in an AI workflow, where every planned shot is created, reviewed and redone until it holds up.
Post-production and delivery. Edit, color, sound, music, voiceover, graphics, then encoding, clearance and trafficking to each broadcaster or streaming service.
When two quotes for the same spot look far apart, check which of these parts each one includes. A low number often covers production and post only. A high number may include concept, talent usage and delivery to every publisher on the media plan.
How TV Commercial Production Has Changed Since 2024
Start with the viewing data. Nielsen's report of The Gauge for May 2025 put it in one sentence, and TV Technology reported the same figures:
"Streaming represented 44.8% of TV viewership in May 2025, its largest share of viewing to date, while broadcast (20.1%) and cable (24.1%) combined to represent 44.2% of TV."
For a producer this means a TV spot is now usually several files. One master goes to linear stations, and other encodes go to connected TV services that each publish their own specifications. The media side of that shift is covered in the connected TV advertising guide.
Production methods changed over the same period. In July 2025 the IAB's 2025 Digital Video Ad Spend and Strategy report stated that "GenAI is now essential for video ad creation, with 86% of buyers using/planning to use it to build video ad creative." TV Technology carried the same number. IAB chief executive David Cohen drew the business conclusion in that release:
"The economics of advertising are being transformed. As the costs of production fall, the opportunities for advertisers multiply"
Cohen added that marketers now look for partners who can help them get strategic and creative value from these tools, beyond simple access to them. The tools are widely available, so the fee a buyer pays goes to a team that can turn them into a finished and cleared spot.
Viewers have their own opinion of AI in ads. In January 2026 the IAB published research showing that advertisers read viewers badly on this subject. Its release on the AI Transparency and Disclosure Framework reports that "82% of advertising executives believe Gen Z and Millennial consumers feel positively about AI-generated ads, however only 45% of these consumers actually feel that way." Tubefilter reported the same pair of figures. A spot that looks cheap or synthetic now carries a cost in trust, which is why finishing quality matters more in 2026 than it did when AI video was a novelty.
Traditional TV Commercial Production: How It Works
The traditional route runs through three parties. The brand writes a brief. An advertising agency develops the idea and the script. A production company, chosen through a bidding process, shoots the film with a director, and an editorial or post house finishes it.
The Association of Independent Commercial Producers has long published rules for that bidding process. Its national guidelines for live action production open with a line that applies to any production method:
"The most important component in production is clear and specific communication between the production company and contracting-client."
The same document explains what a bid really is: "A bid proposal is more than simply an allocation of dollars". The guidelines treat it as the written form of the creative agreement between client and production company. A buyer who reads a quote only for its total is skipping the part that says what will be on screen.
On a set, a director makes decisions with actors in the room. Real fabric, food, skin and metal behave the way real materials behave. If the idea depends on a famous face or a documentary moment, a camera is still the right tool.
That control comes with rigidity. Once the crew wraps, the footage is fixed, and any change to casting, location or weather means another shoot day. Each extra version, such as a new language or a different season, adds cost in talent fees and crew time. Schedules stretch because so many people and places must line up on the same dates.
AI TV Commercial Production: How It Actually Works in 2026
An AI spot keeps every stage of a commercial except the shoot. The brief, the script and the storyboard are written by people. Look development fixes how the characters, the product and the world appear, so that every shot matches the others. Then each shot is generated, judged against the board, and regenerated until it passes. Edit, color, sound, music and voiceover follow in the same finishing software a filmed spot would use.
Kantar's creative team, in its review of generative AI in advertising, quoted OpenAI's Brad Lightcap telling the Cannes Lions audience that "these tools still fundamentally need humans to be creative". The same article asked the question buyers should keep in view: "With the onset of generative AI's potential to create ads at scale, is the industry in danger of creating ineffective content efficiently?"
In practice the human jobs on an AI spot are a creative director who holds the idea, a director who judges performance and framing shot by shot, an editor, a colorist, a sound designer and a producer who owns schedule and rights. What disappears is travel, location permits, set construction and most of the weather risk. The strongest gain is flexibility after approval. A line of dialogue, a product color or an end card can change without recalling a crew.
Some shots remain difficult. Long continuous dialogue from a realistic human face is the hardest shot to get right. Exact product geometry, small on-pack text and brand logos need careful reference work and often compositing. A studio that hides those limits will show them later in the edit.
AI-Assisted Previsualization and Post-Production in Advertising
Many advertisers meet AI at the two ends of a job before they ever commission a fully generated spot. Previsualization comes before any shooting or generation. Wikipedia's entry on previsualization states the benefit precisely:
"Previsualization's advantage is that it allows a director, cinematographer, production supervisor, or VFX supervisor to experiment with different staging and art direction options, such as lighting, camera placement and movement, stage direction and editing, without incurring actual production costs."
The classic previs deliverable in advertising is the animatic. The storyboard article on Wikipedia defines it: "At its simplest, an animatic is a sequence of still images (usually taken from a storyboard) displayed in sync with rough dialogue (i.e., scratch vocals) or rough soundtrack". It also explains why agencies pay for one: "Editing at the animatic stage can help a production avoid wasting time and resources on the animation of scenes that would otherwise be edited out of the film at a later stage."
Generative tools change the fidelity of that step. A board that used to be pencil frames can now be a moving sequence with lighting, lens choice and a temp voice, ready for a client meeting or a research test. The client approves something close to the final film, and the director arrives on set, or at the generation stage, with fewer open questions. Buyers who have never signed off a board can learn to read one in the video storyboard guide.
The second area is post-production. Wikipedia's post-production article gives the scope: "Post-production includes all stages of production occurring after principal photography or recording individual program segments." It also marks the handover point every producer plans around: "Once the production team is satisfied with the picture editing, the editing is said to be locked."
| Stage | Traditional method | Where AI assists in 2026 | What still needs a person |
|---|---|---|---|
| Storyboard and animatic | Drawn frames cut to a scratch track | Moving previs with look, lens and temp voice | Choosing the idea and the order of shots |
| Casting and look tests | Tapes, fittings, camera tests | Character and wardrobe studies before anyone is booked | Final casting and consent from real talent |
| Edit | Assistant logs and syncs, editor cuts | Transcription, selects, rough assemblies | Rhythm, performance choice, the lock |
| Cleanup and visual effects | Rotoscoping, paint, compositing by hand | Faster masks, object removal, set extension | Shot approval at full resolution |
| Color | Colorist grades shot by shot | Shot matching and first-pass balance | The look, skin tones, product color accuracy |
| Sound | Recorded voice, foley, licensed music | Temp voice and music, dialogue cleanup | Final mix, loudness compliance, licenses |
| Versioning | Re-edits by hand for each length and ratio | Reframing, resizing, language variants | Legal lines, claims and local rules |
Take color. Wikipedia calls color grading "a post-production process common to filmmaking and video editing of altering the appearance of an image for presentation in different environments on different devices." Software can balance shots against each other in seconds. Deciding that the car paint matches the showroom sample remains a human sign-off.
Union rules treat these long-standing uses calmly. The law firm Davis+Gilbert, in its summary of the SAG-AFTRA Commercials Contract that took effect in 2025, explains that visual effects, CGI and motion capture remain permitted for their traditional purposes even when the software includes AI, and adds: "No additional permission from, or payment to, performers or the union is necessary. The ongoing use of these ubiquitous tools is not impacted by the new Commercials Contract." Each finishing stage and its timing is described in the video post-production guide.
The Hybrid Approach: How Most Smart Brands Are Producing in 2026
Hybrid production means filmed and generated material inside one spot or one campaign. A common split keeps the camera for the shots that depend on a real performer or a real product in hand, then generates the environments, the transitions, the impossible camera moves and the seasonal variants.
The campaign version of hybrid is just as common. A brand films one hero commercial for its main flight, then commissions generated spots for regional offers, retail partners and connected TV tests through the year. The filmed spot sets the look. The generated work extends it at a pace a crew cannot match.
Hybrid work adds one obligation that pure routes avoid. When a real performer appears next to generated material, or is altered by it, consent and contract terms apply. Davis+Gilbert notes that the 2025 agreement "introduces a formal framework for the ethical use of digital replicas and synthetic performers" and defines the second category clearly: "synthetic performers are entirely fabricated by AI and are not based on the traits, mannerisms or likeness of any specific person." Before altering any real person's image or voice, check what a talent release form must cover.
How AI-Generated TV Ad Creative Compares to Traditionally Produced Spots
The best public evidence on this comparison comes from Kantar, which tests ads with real viewers. In December 2025 Research Live reported on Kantar's testing of AI-generated ads, including two Coca-Cola holiday commercials. Kantar's earlier analysis of AI-made work, the article says, "found a range of performances across AI-generated adverts, with the same spread of distribution as ads created by traditional means". Lynne Deason, Kantar's head of creative excellence, explained what separates the good from the bad:
"having consumer insight, being bold in creative, having brand centricity. All the things that we would say matter still matter the most, but when generative AI is obvious or poorly integrated, it can hurt performance."
Deason was specific about the failure mode: "Where generative AI feels obvious or if something doesn't look quite right, that can create a sense of confusion or a disconnect for people." On realistic humans she added: "When you're trying to portray real people using generative AI, you've got to make sure they look real, and the tech is getting better at doing that". She also flagged a pattern every brand manager should check in the edit: "We see that branding tends to be a little bit lower in generative AI ads."
Her reason for caring about faces applies to any commercial: "Emotion is key to effectiveness, because we pay attention to things that make us feel something, and because it shapes whether we're likely to remember something or not." A TV buy is paid for in memory, which is why ad recall is the usual measure of a spot.
| Factor | Traditional shoot | AI production | Hybrid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Human performance | Strongest, directed live | Hardest area, best kept short or stylized | Filmed for key moments |
| Product accuracy | Real product on camera | Needs references and compositing | Filmed or composited hero shots |
| Worlds and scale | Limited by budget and physics | Wide range without travel | Generated around filmed action |
| Changes after approval | Reshoot or live with it | Regenerate the shot | Depends on which part changes |
| Versions and lengths | Each adds edit and talent cost | Built into the plan | Generated variants from one look |
| Schedule risk | Weather, permits, availability | Review rounds and approvals | Both, in smaller doses |
| Paperwork | Releases, locations, music | Tool terms, likeness, music, disclosure | All of the above |
| Viewer risk | Dull idea | Visible artifacts, weak branding | Mismatch between the two looks |
Judge an AI spot by the standard used for a filmed one, with two extra checks. Look for anything that seems off at full size on a large screen, and confirm the brand is present early and clearly.
Is AI-Generated Ad Creative Good Enough for Premium Placements?
Yes, when the spot passes the same three gates as any other commercial: technical delivery, clearance and disclosure. A broadcaster or streaming service judges the file and the claims. The production method enters only where a rule mentions it.
Delivery specifications for broadcast and CTV.
Every publisher issues its own specification sheet, and the media agency or trafficking partner will send the current one. The published examples agree on the basics. Quantcast's CTV creative specifications ask for a 16:9 picture at 1920x1080 and state that "Fifteen (15) sec and Thirty (30) sec lengths are recommended." Vizio's in-stream video specification lists the same 1920 by 1080 dimensions in an MP4 file with H.264 video. Adobe's ad specifications give the audio rule for connected TV: "Audio Levels: 24 LKFS (+/- 2.0 dB) in the US as per ATSC A/85".
| Item | Typical requirement | Why it matters for AI footage |
|---|---|---|
| Picture | 1920x1080, 16:9, no black bars | Generated shots must be finished at full HD or higher, never upscaled carelessly |
| File | MP4 with H.264 for most CTV, mezzanine file for linear stations | One master, several encodes |
| Frame rate | Constant, as the publisher specifies | Mixed frame rates from different generators cause stutter |
| Audio loudness | 24 LKFS target in the US under ATSC A/85 | A proper mix is required, generated audio included |
| Lengths | 15 and 30 seconds most common | Plan cutdowns in the script |
| Identification | An Ad-ID code per version | Each generated variant is a separate asset |
Loudness has legal force in the United States. Wikipedia's entry on the CALM Act says the law "requires the U.S. Federal Communications Commission to bar the audio of TV commercials from being broadcast louder than the TV program material they accompany". Asset tracking is standardized as well: "Ad-ID is the advertising industry standard unique identifier for all commercial assets airing in the United States similar in concept to the UPC barcode used on retail products." That line comes from Wikipedia's Ad-ID entry. Standard lengths by channel are listed in the guide to how long commercials are.
Clearance.
Clearance checks what the ad says and shows. In the United States the networks run their own review. Wikipedia describes Broadcast Standards and Practices as "the department at a television network which is responsible for the moral, ethical, and legal implications of the program that the network airs". Expect requests for substantiation of every factual claim.
The United Kingdom centralizes the step. Clearcast's guide to ad clearance is direct about timing: "The first stage of every clearance, even if your ad is already made, is to submit your script via The Clearcast Library." It also asks for everything on screen: "All onscreen text, both creative and legal, must be included in the script."
AI changes none of this. The law firm Lewis Silkin, summarizing UK regulator guidance on AI-generated ads, writes: "Even if marketing campaigns are entirely generated or distributed using automated methods, the advertiser remains responsible for the ad." Its summary of the test is one line: "As usual, the claims have to be true, not misleading and substantiated." A generated shot that makes a product look larger, faster or more effective than it is fails for the same reason a retouched one would.
Disclosure and rights.
Disclosure rules are new, and they are narrower than many marketers assume. The IAB framework released in January 2026, according to the IAB's own release, "introduces a risk-based model that avoids blanket labeling and instead calls for disclosure only when AI materially affects the authenticity, identity, or representation in ways that may mislead consumers." Caroline Giegerich, who leads AI at the IAB, gave the reason: "AI is reshaping how advertising is created and scaled, but trust is what will determine its longevity".
State law is moving too. The law firm Cooley reports that New York enacted a synthetic performer law "requiring advertisers to make a conspicuous disclosure in advertisements that include certain digitally created human images, including those generated using artificial intelligence (AI)". Platforms add their own rules. YouTube's help page on AI disclosure says: "we require creators to disclose content that is generated or meaningfully altered with AI when it appears realistic."
Premium streamers hold their own productions to strict standards, and those standards are a useful benchmark for advertisers. Netflix's guidance for production partners warns that "AI-only output may not be protected by copyright, so key creative elements (main/secondary characters, creature designs, hero props, fictional settings) should incorporate meaningful human authorship." It also names a risk buyers rarely consider: "generative tools can reproduce copyright-protected works, trademarks, or trade dress even without being prompted to." The licenses a finished spot should carry are set out in the guide to video usage rights and licensing.
Premium placement readiness checklist.
Use this list before a generated or hybrid spot goes to a network or a streaming service.
- Script and storyboard approved in writing, with every on-screen line of text listed
- Substantiation file for each factual claim, ready for network review
- Master finished at full HD or higher and reviewed at full size on a large screen
- No visible artifacts in hands, faces, text, logos or product shape
- Brand visible and named in the opening seconds
- Audio mixed by an engineer to the publisher's loudness target
- One encode per publisher specification, each with its own Ad-ID
- Written consent for any real person's likeness or voice, including digital replicas
- Music, voice and font licenses that cover television and the campaign dates
- Record of which shots were generated and with which tools, kept by the producer
- Decision on disclosure taken with legal counsel for each market and platform
TV Commercial Production Costs in 2026
Published price ranges for commercials vary so widely that a single number tells a buyer little. The cost drivers are more useful than averages. Sourced figures are in the breakdown of what a 30-second commercial costs. This section explains what moves a quote up or down.
A filmed job is priced mainly by shoot days. Director, crew, cast, locations, equipment, travel and insurance scale with the number of shoot days. Talent usage fees then scale with the media plan, since a national flight costs more in rights than a regional test.
An AI job is priced mainly by how difficult the shots are and how many review rounds they need. Realistic humans who speak, exact product replicas and long continuous shots take more generation and more finishing than stylized worlds or product-led montage. The number of approval rounds matters as much as the shot count.
Some costs stay the same on both routes. Concept and script, music licensing, voiceover, the sound mix, clearance and trafficking are needed either way. Voice rights follow their own pricing logic, explained in the commercial voice over guide. A fair comparison puts quotes side by side with identical scope: the same lengths, the same number of versions, the same rights and the same list of delivery files.
Choosing the Right Approach for Your Commercial
The choice depends on what the spot must do and what it must show. Score your project against these questions, one point per answer, and see which column collects the most.
| Question | Points to a shoot | Points to AI production | Points to hybrid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Does the idea rest on a named person or a real customer? | Yes | No | Partly |
| Must the physical product be handled on screen? | Throughout | Rarely | In a few shots |
| Does the story need places you cannot film? | No | Yes | Some |
| How many versions will the media plan need? | One or two | Many | Many, from one look |
| How soon is the air date? | Months away | Weeks away | In between |
| Will the script change after approval? | Unlikely | Likely | Possibly |
| Is there existing footage that sets the look? | It is the plan | No | Yes |
A hero film built on an actor's performance belongs on a set. A product story told through design, motion and atmosphere suits AI production well. A campaign that needs both a centerpiece and a long tail of variants usually ends up hybrid.
Before committing to a route, test the weakest shot. Ask the producer to show the hardest moment in the script as a short test: the close-up, the pour, the logo on a curved surface. If that shot works, the rest of the spot is a matter of schedule.
Who Can Shoot and Produce a Great TV Commercial?
Three kinds of company can take a brief to air, and they answer for different things. Wikipedia's definition of an advertising agency covers the first: "An advertising agency, often referred to as a creative agency or an ad agency, is a business dedicated to creating, planning, and handling advertising and sometimes other forms of promotion and marketing for its clients."
The production company is the maker. In Wikipedia's words: "It handles budgeting, scheduling, scripting, the supply with talent and resources, the organization of staff, the production itself, post-production, distribution, and marketing." Inside it, the producer runs the money and the calendar. The entry for line producer is specific: "Line producers also manage scheduling and the budget of a motion picture, as well as day-to-day physical aspects of the film production."
An AI production studio combines parts of both roles. It writes or adapts the script, directs, generates and finishes under one roof, and it sells to brands directly or to agencies as a white-label supplier.
| Who | What they own | Hire them when | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Advertising agency | Strategy, idea, script, media relationship | The campaign idea is still open | Production is subcontracted, so ask who makes the film |
| Production company | Director, crew, shoot, delivery of the film | The script is approved and needs a set | Bids assume a fixed script |
| Post house | Edit, color, visual effects, sound, masters | Footage exists and needs finishing | Scope creep in revisions |
| AI production studio | Script to master without a shoot | The idea suits generated footage and time is short | Proof of broadcast finishing and rights handling |
| In-house team | Brand knowledge, fast approvals | Volume is high and formats repeat | Limited range of looks |
The quality of the finished spot depends on named people more than on company type. Ask who directs, who edits, who grades and who signs off the mix. A seller who cannot name them has probably not staffed the job yet.
Working with TV Commercial Production Companies
A few questions separate reliable suppliers from the rest, whatever tools they use.
Ask to see finished work at full resolution, with sound, on a large screen. Compressed social clips hide the faults that a living-room television reveals. Ask what happens when a shot fails review: how many rounds are included and who decides. Ask for the delivery list in writing, including lengths, aspect ratios, encodes and captions.
Then ask about rights. Who owns the master, which licenses cover music and voice, and what the supplier's tools allow for commercial use. Netflix's partner guidance states a good principle for any brand: "avoid content that could mislead viewers or be mistaken for real events, people, or statements that didn't occur." A longer list of selection criteria is in the framework for choosing a video production agency.
Neverframe is an AI video production studio that makes films, spots, social ads and avatars to order for brands and agencies. A spot is a 30-second commercial with script, storyboard, licensed music, sound design and voiceover, delivered as a 4K master plus a vertical version in two weeks. A first version arrives within days. Agencies can use the studio as a white-label partner through the partners page. If you have a script or only a product and a date, see the four formats or send the brief.
What to Brief, What to Buy, and What to Expect
A brief for a TV spot needs six things: the business goal, the audience, the single message, the mandatory elements such as claims and legal lines, the media plan, and the air date. Leave the execution open. A producer who knows the plan includes connected TV and vertical placements will frame shots differently from one who expects a single 16:9 file.
The purchase order should list deliverables as files. Write down each length, each aspect ratio, each language and each publisher specification. Add the rights: territory, media, term, and any talent or voice usage. Add the review plan: who approves the script, the storyboard, the offline edit and the final master, and how many rounds each stage includes.
Expect the first cut to look unfinished on any route. On a filmed job the offline edit has temp sound and ungraded pictures. On an AI job early versions may contain placeholder shots that are still in generation. Judge story and timing at that stage, and judge polish at the end.
Plan for clearance time. Networks and clearance bodies review scripts and finished films on their own schedule, and a claim that needs evidence can add days. Submitting the script before production starts is the cheapest insurance a buyer can take out.
The Bottom Line on TV Commercial Production in 2026
AI has made the shoot optional for a large share of commercials. A spot still needs a strong idea, a director, careful finishing and clean paperwork before it can air. Filmed production keeps its lead where a real performance or a real object carries the film. AI production leads where speed, range and versions matter.
To test this on your own media plan, pick one spot from next quarter, write the brief described above, and ask for a storyboard and one test shot before approving the full job. Brands can start on the Neverframe brands page. Agencies that want a white-label production partner can start with the partners page, or simply contact the studio.
FAQ
How long does TV commercial production take in 2026?
It depends on the route and on how fast approvals move. A filmed commercial has to line up director, cast, crew and location dates, then pass through edit, color and sound, so the calendar is set by availability. An AI-produced spot skips the shoot. At Neverframe a 30-second spot is delivered in two weeks, with a first version in a few days. On either route, add time for network or clearance review, which runs on the reviewer's schedule.
Can AI-generated commercials run on linear TV and premium streaming?
Yes. Broadcasters and streaming services assess the delivered file and the claims in the ad. The spot must meet the publisher's picture and audio specifications, pass clearance with substantiated claims, and carry the right licenses and consents. Disclosure applies in defined cases, such as synthetic performers under New York law or realistic altered content on some platforms. A generated spot that meets those conditions is eligible for the same inventory as a filmed one.
How does AI-generated TV ad creative compare to traditionally produced ads?
Kantar's testing, reported by Research Live in December 2025, found that AI-generated ads show the same spread of results as traditionally made ads. Strong ideas with clear branding perform well on both routes. The specific risks of AI work are visible artifacts, unconvincing human faces and weaker branding. Review the film at full size on a large screen, and check that the brand appears early, before approving the master.
Who produces a TV commercial: the agency, a production company or a studio?
All three can, in different roles. An advertising agency owns the strategy and the idea and usually hires a production company to film it. The production company supplies the director, the crew and the finished film. An AI production studio covers script, direction, generation and finishing in one team and works for brands directly or for agencies as a white-label supplier. Ask any of them to name the director, editor and colorist on your job.
Do AI commercials need a disclosure label?
Sometimes. The IAB's 2026 framework recommends disclosure only when AI materially affects authenticity, identity or representation in a way that could mislead viewers. New York requires a conspicuous disclosure when an ad includes a synthetic performer, and some platforms require labels for realistic generated content. Rules differ by market and by publisher, so the decision belongs with your legal counsel. Keep a production record of what was generated so that the question can be answered quickly.