Holiday Ads: What Works, What to Make
What makes holiday ads work: famous examples compared, formats by channel, music rights, and what a brand can still produce in late November.
Published 2026-06-27 · Updated 2026-11-17 · Video Marketing · By Tommaso Maria Ricci, Founder of Neverframe
Most of the holiday ads people can still name are reruns. Coca-Cola has sent a convoy of lit trucks through the snow since 1995. Hershey's has rung the same chocolate bells since 1989. Both still reach the top score in consumer testing. A holiday ad works when it makes people feel something warm, when viewers know within seconds whose ad it is, and when the brand can run it again next year. The money at stake explains the effort. The National Retail Federation forecast published on October 15 reads:
"The National Retail Federation today released its annual holiday forecast, predicting retail sales in November and December will grow 4.2% over 2025. That translates to total spending of $1.013 trillion."
Retail Dive reported the same forecast and noted that 2025 holiday sales had grown 3.1% to $972 billion. NRF chief executive Matthew Shay summed up the mood in the release: "This year's forecast reflects our confidence that consumers will prioritize the holiday season even as they remain mindful of their budgets."
What the best holiday ads have in common
Lists of the best holiday ads tend to repeat the same handful of names. Most of the films are old, most are simple, and almost none of them mention price.
| Campaign | Brand | First aired | What it shows | Documented result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Holidays are Coming | Coca-Cola | 1995 | A convoy of red trucks covered in lights crossing a snowy landscape | Maximum 5.9-Star rating in System1 testing, repeated across several years |
| Christmas Bells | Hershey's Kisses | December 1989 | Kisses arranged as a handbell choir playing a carol, 15 seconds, no dialogue | Longest-running commercial in Hershey's history |
| They Do Exist | M&M's | 1996 | Red and Yellow meet Santa on Christmas Eve, and Santa faints | Returns to screens every year, with a sequel in 2017 |
| John Lewis Christmas advert | John Lewis | 2007 | A new short story each year, usually set to a slowed-down cover song | Top prize at the 2012 IPA Effectiveness Awards |
| Misunderstood | Apple | Holiday 2013 | A teenager who seems glued to his phone turns out to be filming the family | 2014 Creative Arts Emmy for Outstanding Commercial |
| 1914 | Sainsbury's | November 2014 | A re-enactment of the Christmas truce, made with The Royal British Legion | A replica of the chocolate bar in the film sold to benefit the Legion |
| Secret Santa | Cadbury | Repeat of earlier work | A returning campaign about giving chocolate in secret | Most effective UK Christmas ad of 2025 in Kantar testing |
Wikipedia's account of the campaign describes the original film in one sentence:
"Debuted in 1995, the "Holidays are coming!" advertisement featured a train of red delivery trucks, emblazoned with the Coca-Cola name and decorated with Christmas lights, driving through a snowy landscape"
There is no offer and no product claim in that description. The film built an asset that belongs to one company. System1, the ad testing firm that has scored the campaign since 2013, explains in its five lessons from the Christmas trucks why that matters:
"The trucks are particularly strong because no other brand has anything like them. While Coke may feel a special claim to Santa, the fact is that any brand can and does use him. But the trucks are truly distinctive."
The Hershey's spot is far smaller and has lasted longer. The Hershey Company tells the origin story this way: "John Dunn, Hershey's brand manager at the time, created the 15-second stop-motion animation featuring Hershey's Kisses as handbells". The company adds a line worth remembering before anyone books a celebrity:
"The ad is Hershey's longest-running commercial ever and evokes the entire holiday spirit without a single spoken word or celebrity."
When System1 tested the spot in 2018, its writer admitted he had assumed it was a new film made for digital. His review of Christmas Bells lists the reasons it still fits modern media: "It's short. It uses sound beautifully, but doesn't rely on being audible. It's delightfully simple, immediately recognisable, and very tastefully designed."
M&M's took the same road with humor. System1's study of repeated Christmas ads says of the Santa spot: "Originally aired in 1996, the commercial continues returning to screens each year." Marketing Dive, in a roundup of holiday ads that have stood the test of time, credits the film with combining humor and nostalgia, and says of the Hershey's bells: "Sometimes the simplest ideas are the best."
John Lewis makes a new film every year, and the release date has become a fixture of the British calendar. According to Wikipedia, the retailer launched its first Christmas advert in 2007, and:
"It has since become something of an annual tradition in the UK, and one of the signals that the countdown to Christmas has begun."
Apple's film gave the product a role in a family story and, as iMore reported, "Apple has won an Emmy Award for the category of outstanding commercial in 2014 for its Misunderstood ad." The Television Academy lists the same award. Sainsbury's tied its film to a cause. In a statement quoted by Shoot, the grocer said: "Working with The Royal British Legion, we have chosen to do this through the lens of one of the most extraordinary moments of sharing in modern history". The same report notes that the film divided opinion, which is the risk of borrowing a real historical event for a retail message.
Why a holiday advertisement gets stronger with repetition
Marketing teams get tired of their own work long before the audience does, and the research on seasonal advertising keeps finding it. The wear-in study describes the habit:
"Marketers are often the first to tire of their campaigns, and assume that viewers feel the same way. This results in brands launching new ads on a regular basis, sometimes several times per year."
The firm compared ads tested soon after launch with ads tested years later and found little evidence that familiar ads lose their effect. Its conclusion for seasonal work:
"Christmas and holiday ads have a short lifespan, typically from November 1 through the end of the year. But if they're effective at entertaining viewers, these ads not only drive sales during the all-important festive period but continue to build brands over the long term."
Coca-Cola is the reference case. System1's rating scale runs from 1 to 5.9 Stars, and the firm says only 1% of ads reach the 5-Star range. When Advanced Television covered the 2023 results, it reported that Holidays are Coming had secured the highest possible rating of 5.9 and quoted System1's Jon Evans: "Every year the Christmas trucks roll for Coke and every year Holidays are Coming scores 5-Stars. In fact it's the yardstick of Christmas advertising." System1's own 2019 analysis used almost the same words about staying power:
"Defying conventional advertising wisdom, which says ads wear out with the public, "Holidays Are Coming!" keeps its appeal, year on year."
Kantar's 2025 consumer testing of UK Christmas ads, reported by Retail Times and Consultancy.uk, found that five of the ten best-performing TV spots reused previous ads, with Cadbury's Secret Santa first and the Coca-Cola trucks second. Lynne Deason, head of creative excellence at Kantar, did not soften the point:
"In a cluttered season, brands reusing and evolving familiar assets are cutting through more effectively than those starting from scratch. That's not lazy, it's smart marketing."
She added a condition that keeps the finding from turning into an excuse to rerun anything: "Effective advertising takes more than simple repetition. Brands need a clear, core idea, rooted in their strategy, that can be refreshed and adapted to trends and consumer realities."
Audiences accept small updates and punish real changes to something they love. When Hershey's released a new version of the bells film in 2020, with a child's hand taking one of the Kisses, the reaction was immediate. Wikipedia records the outcome:
"However, the new version was met with backlash mainly for being changed. The company did respond to the backlash, announcing that both versions would be aired."
Production technology has been tested the same way. Coca-Cola remade the trucks film with generative AI in 2024 and again in 2025, and both versions drew criticism online. System1 put the 2025 film in front of its consumer panel and published the result under the title AI or No AI, Coke Gets the Christmas Love. The film again received the maximum score. The trucks, the snow, the music and the watching crowd were all still there:
"But viewers never mind the changes, as long as those ingredients are all present."
System1's conclusion on the production method: "The lesson for Coke from Test Your Ad is that using AI doesn't hurt ordinary viewers' enjoyment of the ad at all". The same article adds that the brand is wise not to mention AI in the ad itself.
A buyer should therefore commission a holiday film as a multi-year asset, with usage rights, music terms and master files that allow it to return. System1's first lesson from the trucks is addressed to the people who approve the work: "You'll get bored of a good idea before your audience will".
The emotional mechanics of a holiday advert
Seasonal work sits at the warm end of advertising, and the scores reflect it. System1 notes in its roundup of US holiday favorites: "Overall, only 1% of ads land in the 5-Star range. But many brands save their best, most emotional work for Christmas and the wider holiday season, when 5-Star ads are more common." In its review of the 2025 Coca-Cola film the firm gives the reason:
"Holiday ads generally score higher than ordinary ads, because there's so much more emphasis in them on positive emotion, but a 5.9-Star result is exceptional at any time of year."
The films that score well tell a story with people or characters in it. System1's review of the 2024 season found that the strongest work in both the UK and the US put brand building ahead of selling: "A focus on character, storytelling, and scenery drove stronger results across the board." The weakest work did the reverse. Many November ads in that review produced no short-term effect at all, and the firm described what they looked like: "These ads often relied on rational, sales-driven messaging, featuring flat backdrops, heavy voiceovers, and explicit calls to action." The evidence behind this is laid out in emotional ads and why they work.
Aldi's Kevin the Carrot, the M&M's pair and the Coca-Cola trucks carry the brand through a story without a logo in every frame. Retail Times notes that Aldi's 2025 film simply continued the adventures of Kevin the Carrot and that Marks and Spencer brought back its Fairy. Budweiser's Clydesdales are the long-running American equivalent outside the season: Anheuser-Busch dates the first hitch to April 1933, when it marked the repeal of Prohibition.
The season is also built on rituals, and ads that join a ritual borrow its warmth. System1 observed that Walmart, Chex and Pillsbury all leaned on shared memories in 2024, from old films to the Thanksgiving table. A borrowed memory that has nothing to do with the brand tends to help the memory more than the advertiser, a point developed in nostalgia ads.
Long emotional films have a known weakness: viewers enjoy them and forget who paid. System1 flags it for the long British formats in particular:
"In the UK, where many Christmas ads run over 40 seconds, creativity is crucial. Ensuring that audiences recognize the ad as being for your brand requires frequent, early, and repeated brand cues."
Consistency is the cheapest fix. The same review says: "Brands that re-air ads or repurpose characters and soundtracks during Christmas drive increased fluency year after year."
At script stage, ask someone outside the team to read the script with the brand name removed and say which company it is for. If the answer could be any retailer, the film needs an owned element before it needs a bigger production.
Holiday ad formats and lengths by channel
Television is still where a seasonal idea becomes famous, and the other channels now carry more of the weight after that. Kantar's 2025 study found that one in four UK consumers looked forward to watching Christmas ads on YouTube and 18% on TikTok. Deason describes the division of labor:
"While television is still incredibly important for landing a central idea and making it famous, non-traditional media formats are doing more of the heavy lifting in terms of magnifying and extending the impact of campaigns."
Most holiday media plans ask for the same idea in the following cuts.
| Channel | Typical cut | Aspect ratio | What the cut has to do |
|---|---|---|---|
| Linear TV and connected TV | 30-second spot, with a 15-second version | 16:9 | Land the story and the brand asset with sound on |
| Online film and brand channels | 60 to 90 seconds | 16:9 | Tell the full story for people who choose to watch |
| YouTube skippable in-stream | 15 to 30 seconds | 16:9 | Show the brand before the skip button appears |
| YouTube bumper | 6 seconds | 16:9 | Remind viewers of the main film with one image and the sound cue |
| Reels, TikTok, Shorts, Stories | 15 seconds, several hooks | 9:16 | Earn attention in the first second, work with sound off |
| Feed placements | 15 seconds | 1:1 | Carry the offer or the gift idea with on-screen text |
The YouTube rows follow the platform's rules. Google's overview of video ad formats says of skippable in-stream ads: "Viewers can skip the ad after 5 seconds." It defines the shortest format as follows:
"Bumper ads are non-skippable video ads lasting between 5 and 6 seconds that play before, during, or after another video."
Google's Display and Video 360 documentation gives the same six-second ceiling and says when the format fits: "Use bumper ads when you want to reach viewers with a short, memorable message that cannot be skipped."
A film that saves the brand for the final frame, the way a two-minute cinema piece can, loses most of a skippable audience before the reveal. The Hershey's bells are a useful model for short formats: the product is the cast, so every second is branded.
Shoot or generate the vertical version as its own composition, because a 9:16 crop of a wide shot usually cuts off the action. Decide the lengths before the script is locked, since a story written for 60 seconds rarely survives being cut to 15. Standard lengths are explained in how long commercials are, and current platform dimensions in the social media video specs guide.
Music and rights in holidays advertising
The Coca-Cola jingle, the Hershey's carol and the John Lewis cover are each half of the memory of those films. The US holiday roundup from System1 explains why:
"Melodic music that you can easily sing or hum attracts the broad-beam attention of the right brain, making it an effective tool for building memory structures among a wider audience."
The firm ties sound to the way people watch television at home, half-listening from another room or looking at a phone: "Audio, therefore, becomes a powerful memory tool. Brands should consider building a narrative voice, jingle, or soundtrack into their communications consistently to enhance recall." Kantar's 2025 study found the same pull. Amazon's instrumental cover of a Beatles song scored highest for music enjoyment, with the Coca-Cola jingle close behind.
John Lewis turned the cover version into a signature. Wikipedia notes that the songs are frequently covers of existing songs and adds: "They have often reached high positions on the UK Singles Chart, and the original versions often receive a sales boost." The 2013 film used Lily Allen's version of a Keane song, which went to number one in the UK according to both the advert's page and the song's own entry.
Covers are common for a contractual reason as much as a creative one. Every commercial recording carries two sets of rights. Wikipedia's entry on synchronization rights sets out who has to be asked:
"When an audio/visual project producer wants to use a recording in their work, they must contact both the owner of the sound recording (record label of the performer), and the owner of the composition (publishing company of the songwriter)."
The same entry describes the route most advertisers take when the famous recording is out of reach: "In many cases, producers with tight budgets will elect to use a cover version of a particular song or work with independent artists in order to save money on the master side."
The music choices on a holiday brief look like this.
- License a famous recording: two negotiations, the longest lead time, and terms that often cover one season only.
- Commission a cover of a known song: one negotiation with the publisher, plus a new recording the brand controls.
- Commission an original score or jingle that the brand can own outright.
- Use a traditional carol in a new arrangement, as Hershey's did. Each recording and each modern arrangement still carries its own rights, so confirm the status title by title.
The license should match the plan to bring the film back. Ask for the term, the territories, the media and the cost of renewal in writing before the edit is locked. The contract side is covered in the sync license for ads guide, and the long-term value of an owned sound in sonic branding examples and famous commercial jingles.
A production calendar that works backward from air dates
The season starts earlier than most plans assume. NRF's own definition: "NRF defines the holiday season as Nov. 1 through Dec. 31." Retail has been stretching that window for years, a habit with its own Wikipedia entry:
"Christmas creep (also referred to as holiday creep) is a merchandising phenomenon in which merchants and retailers introduce holiday-themed merchandise, decorations or music well before the traditional start of a holiday shopping season."
Large advertisers plan accordingly. System1 notes that some of the season's films "have been in development since the beginning of the calendar year." A brand without that runway can still plan well by fixing the air dates first and counting backward. For 2026 the dates that matter in the US are set out in the next grid, with the latest sensible brief date for a studio that delivers a finished spot in about two weeks, plus a few working days for platform review. A film on a three to four week schedule needs earlier dates.
| Air date in 2026 | What should be live | Brief signed by, for a two-week delivery |
|---|---|---|
| November 1 | Main brand film and first gifting messages | Mid-October |
| Thanksgiving, November 26 | Hosting, food and travel messages | About November 9 |
| Black Friday, November 27, to Cyber Monday, November 30 | Offer-led spots and social ads | About November 10 |
| First two weeks of December | Gift guides, delivery cut-off reminders | November 17 to 24 |
| Super Saturday, December 19 | Last-minute and in-store messages | About December 2 |
| Christmas week, December 21 to 25 | Thank-you and brand messages | About December 4 |
| December 26 to January 1 | Year-end message, gift cards, new year offers | About December 9 |
For next year's main film the work runs in this order.
- Audit what the brand already owns: characters, music, a store, a line, a color.
- Write the idea so it can return, and say in the brief whether the film is meant for one season or five.
- Test the script before production. System1 says brands that pre-test their Christmas work see higher ratings. Stage lengths for a conventional shoot are in the video production timeline guide.
- Produce the master and every cut together, with vertical, square and six-second versions planned at script stage.
- Clear music and usage for the full plan, including renewal.
- Put next November's flight in the calendar the day the film ships.
What can still be produced in late November
By the third week of November, Black Friday creative should already be finished and trafficked. A film that depends on casting, locations, snow and a licensed hit record is out of reach on a conventional schedule. Several useful things are still within range, especially with AI-assisted production that needs no shoot days.
- A 30-second spot for the December gifting weeks, briefed now and delivered in early December.
- A set of vertical social ads with different opening hooks for the same offer, so the media team can find the winner before Super Saturday.
- Six-second bumpers that repeat one image and one sound from the main film.
- A delivery cut-off message for e-commerce, which has a hard date and a clear job.
- A thank-you film for Christmas week, addressed to customers or staff, with no offer in it.
- A year-end message from the chief executive, recorded as an avatar if the diary does not allow a shoot.
The big emotional film with a new character and a famous song should wait. That kind of work pays back over several seasons, so it deserves a proper script, a pre-test and clean rights.
A late brief needs a few conditions to hold.
- One message per film.
- One owned asset on screen in the first five seconds: a character, a pack shot, a color, a sound.
- Music that is original or already cleared, because there is no time left for a publisher negotiation.
- Formats, lengths and air dates listed in the brief.
- A single approver who can sign off within a day.
- Usage terms that let the film return next year.
If the plan fits that list, tell us the air date and we will reply with what can be delivered against it.
How a studio like Neverframe produces holiday ads
Neverframe is a production studio that makes films to order for brands and agencies, using AI-driven production under the direction of a creative team. There is no software to learn and nothing to operate. A client briefs the studio the way it would brief any production company and receives finished masters. The work is organized in four formats, described on the page for brands.
| Format | What is delivered | Where it fits in a holiday plan | Timing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Films | A brand film of 60 to 90 seconds with an original script, a cinematic score, a 4K master and cuts for social | The seasonal story the brand intends to bring back each year | Three to four weeks |
| Spots | A 30-second spot with script, storyboard, licensed music, sound design and voiceover, as a 4K master plus a vertical version | TV, connected TV and YouTube during the gifting weeks | Two weeks |
| Social ads | Three 15-second ads with different hooks plus two 6-second bumpers, in 9:16, 1:1 and 16:9 | Offers, gift ideas and cut-off dates across social and YouTube | Two weeks |
| Avatars | A digital double of the chief executive that records new messages without new shoots | Year-end messages to customers, partners and staff | New messages without a new shoot |
A first version arrives within days, and final delivery follows in about two weeks, or three to four for films.
The script and storyboard are approved before anything is rendered, so the brand asset, the opening seconds and the end frame are agreed on paper. Music is either composed for the film or licensed with terms written into the delivery, which keeps the film available for a second season. The vertical and short versions are composed as their own shots.
System1 concluded from the AI version of the Coca-Cola trucks that long-term creative assets matter much more than technology. A studio's job is to protect those assets and make them easier to produce, version and bring back.
Agencies use the same formats under their own name. Neverframe works white label for agency partners, with a first version in 72 hours, and the terms are on the partners page.
Start with one strong film
Coca-Cola's truck tour, the live events and the social content all depend on the television work that came first. System1 puts it this way: "Coke's wisdom lies in realising that their broad-reach TV campaigns were the bedrock which allowed the branded experiences and the buzz around them to work." The same order applies at any budget: one film that makes the idea known, then the shorter cuts and the offers around it.
If you are planning seasonal work for this December or want to start next year's film early, see the four formats on the brands page or send a brief.
FAQ
What makes a holiday ad effective?
Three things, according to the testing data. The ad creates positive emotion, usually through a simple story with people or characters in it. Viewers know early whose ad it is, through an owned asset such as a character, a sound or a color. And the work is consistent from year to year: returning ads such as the Coca-Cola trucks and Cadbury's Secret Santa score at or near the top with System1 and Kantar.
When should brands start producing holiday ads?
Large advertisers begin early in the year, and System1 notes that some seasonal films are in development from the start of the calendar year. NRF defines the holiday season as November 1 through December 31, so the main film should be finished in October. Offer-led spots and social ads for December can be briefed in November with a studio that delivers in about two weeks.
How long should a holiday ad be?
It depends on the channel. Television and connected TV usually run 30-second spots with 15-second versions. Online brand films run 60 to 90 seconds. YouTube bumpers are capped at six seconds, and skippable ads can be skipped after five, so the brand has to appear before that point. Vertical social placements work best at about 15 seconds.
Can you reuse the same holiday advertisement every year?
Yes. Hershey's has aired its Christmas Bells film since 1989 and Coca-Cola has returned to its trucks since 1995. System1 found little evidence that familiar ads lose their effect, and Kantar found that five of the ten best-performing UK Christmas spots of 2025 reused earlier ads. The conditions are contractual: talent, music and usage terms must allow the film to come back.
Is it too late to produce a holiday ad in late November?
It is too late for Black Friday and for a large film with a licensed hit song. It is early enough for a 30-second spot, vertical social ads, six-second bumpers, a delivery cut-off reminder and a year-end message. With a studio that works without shoot days and delivers in about two weeks, a brief signed in the third week of November can be on air for the main gifting weeks of December.